Does Caffeine Cause Stress? Here’s the Surprising Truth

Lexy Pacheco
Reviewed by Lexy Pacheco

Your Morning Coffee Feels Good — But Does It Really Help?
That first sip of coffee gives you an instant boost that helps you focus, shake off sleepiness, and get through your to-do list. But have you ever noticed how quickly that alertness can turn into jittery tension, racing thoughts, or a crash in the afternoon? You aren't imagining things if you use caffeine to "push through" stress and then feel wired but tired by the end of the day. The drink that promises to help you get things done might be making your stress worse without you even knowing it.
The good news is that you don't have to stop drinking coffee to feel better. When and how you drink caffeine, as well as what you drink it with, are the most important things. If you love espresso or just need a boost in the afternoon, small changes can help you get the benefits of caffeine without the side effects of burnout. Let's talk about how to enjoy your coffee and keep your stress under control. You deserve to feel good and have energy.
better with Soula

Support for every woman:
✅ A Personalized Plan to reduce anxiety and overthinking
✅ 24/7 Emotional Support whenever you need it Cycle-Aligned Mental Health Tracking — monitor your mood and symptoms in sync with your period
✅ Real-Time Insights into your energy levels and emotional state
✅ Bite-Sized Exercises to help you return to a calm, balanced state — anytime, anywhere
Does Caffeine Cause Stress?
Caffeine works by blocking adenosine, a brain chemical that makes you feel relaxed and sleepy, and at the same time, it makes adrenaline flow. This one-two punch gives you that familiar burst of energy, but it also makes your nervous system very alert. For a lot of people, this means that their focus is jittery, which means that their mind is sharp but their body is still tense. This effect can make you more productive in small amounts, but when you add caffeine to stress you already have, it can make your body go into overdrive.
Studies have shown that caffeine raises cortisol levels, especially when you drink it on an empty stomach or when you're very stressed. Researchers in Psychosomatic Medicine found that people who drank coffee while under stress had much higher levels of cortisol than people who didn't drink coffee. What did you learn? Caffeine may make you feel worse if you're already stressed out. Mindful consumption is the key; timing and dosage are more important than cutting out everything.
Why Some People React More Strongly
Your genes have a surprising effect on how caffeine affects you. About half of people are "slow metabolizers" because of a change in the CYP1A2 gene. This means that caffeine stays in their bodies longer, which makes its stimulating effects stronger. People who metabolize caffeine quickly, on the other hand, do so well and may not even notice its effects. But genetics aren't the only thing that matters. Anxiety, chronic stress, or not getting enough sleep can make you more sensitive, so even a small cup of coffee can make you feel restless or irritable.
There are different types of caffeine sources. A cup of coffee that you sip slowly (100–200 mg caffeine) gives you a steadier release than energy drinks that are full of sugar and have 300+ mg of caffeine, which can make you feel sharper and crashier. Even soda, which has less caffeine (30 to 50 mg), can keep you awake if you drink it late in the day. Knowing these differences helps you adjust your intake to your level of tolerance, since what is "normal" for one person might be too much for another.
Real-Life Signs Caffeine Might Be Making You More Stressed
That morning latte might promise to help you focus, but if you notice your mind racing or chattering within an hour of drinking it, your caffeine dose might be making you more hyper instead of clearer. Caffeine can help you stay alert, but too much of it or drinking it when you're already stressed can make your mind race through worries or tasks without getting anything done. If you keep thinking about problems or going over conversations in your head after drinking coffee, your nervous system is too excited.
Another warning sign is a tension headache. Caffeine can help some people with headaches (it's a main ingredient in migraine medications), but too much of it can also make them worse. If you often feel a dull, squeezing pain around your temples or the back of your head, especially when your caffeine wears off, it could be a sign that you are dependent on it or going through withdrawal. When you drink too much caffeine over a long period of time, it changes the way blood flows in your brain. If you stop drinking it, you may feel throbbing pain.
If you have the jitters, are irritable, and can't sleep, it's a sure sign that caffeine is stressing you out. If your hands shake, your heart races, or you snap at small things, that's your body telling you that the adrenaline rush is too much. If you're lying in bed with a wide-awake mind even though you're tired, caffeine in the afternoon or evening could be messing up your sleep cycle. Even if you do fall asleep, the quality of your sleep will suffer.
Finally, the afternoon crash, which is when you suddenly feel tired, foggy-headed, or crave more caffeine, is a clear sign that your cortisol levels are out of whack. Caffeine gives you a temporary boost of energy, but when it wears off, your body goes too far and makes you feel even more tired than before. Your ability to handle stress is probably getting worse if you keep going through caffeine highs and lows.
What to Do If You Suspect Caffeine Is Adding to Your Stress
You don't have to quit coffee cold turkey if it feels like both a lifeline and a source of stress. In fact, quitting too quickly can make stress worse. Instead, try to taper off slowly: Every week, cut back on what you eat by 25%. For example, go from 4 cups to 3, then 2. This gentle method helps your body adjust while reducing headaches and tiredness. Another simple solution? You can mix half-caf with regular coffee or switch to green tea, which has L-theanine, an amino acid that helps you stay calm and focused while also keeping you awake.
The time is just as important as the amount. To protect your sleep cycle, drink your last cup of coffee before noon (or at least 8–10 hours before bed). Cortisol levels naturally rise in the morning, so drinking caffeine before 9 AM works with your body's natural rhythms. If you need a pick-me-up in the afternoon, try decaf herbal tea, a brisk walk, or a snack high in protein. These will help you get through the day without stressing out your nervous system too much.
To help your body deal with stress, make sure you drink enough water, eat foods high in magnesium (like leafy greens, nuts, and dark chocolate), and get enough sleep every night. Caffeine lowers magnesium levels, which is a mineral that helps you relax, and dehydration can make you feel anxious. A simple rule: drink the same amount of water as you do coffee. For a week, write down your mood and how much caffeine you drink in a notes app. You might notice patterns, like getting cranky after your second cup or sleeping better on days when you drink less.
Lastly, pay attention to what your body is telling you. Some people do well with one espresso in the morning, while others do better with tea. There isn't a "right" amount; you just have to find what works for you. If you're still stressed after making changes, you might want to take a break from caffeine for a week or two to see how your baseline changes. Keep in mind that the goal isn't to go without, but to get energy that lasts and doesn't make you anxious.
Caffeine and Stress at Work:
A Toxic Combo?
Studies show a worrying cycle: caffeine makes the body's stress response stronger, which means cortisol levels go up even more during stressful times. A study from the University of Bristol found that people who drank coffee at work reported being in a worse mood and having more anxiety than people who drank decaf, especially when they drank caffeine after noon. But in many offices, it's normal to keep getting coffee refills, and people think of coffee as a "productivity fuel" instead of a drug that has real effects on the brain. What happened? People who are jittery think they are focused, but they crash harder later.
To stop being dependent, you need to make small changes and time things better. To avoid dehydration, which can make you feel stressed, try drinking the same amount of water with every cup of coffee. To protect your sleep, switch to herbal tea or decaf after 2 PM. Instead of another espresso, try a 10-minute walk or a snack high in protein to get through the afternoon slump. These will help you get through the dips in energy without overloading your nervous system. Keep in mind that real productivity comes from steady energy, not quick bursts of energy from caffeine and cortisol.
You Don’t Have to Give Up Coffee.
But You Can Give Yourself Peace
You don't have to change your whole life to feel less stressed. Small, thoughtful changes can make a big difference. Drink a glass of water with your coffee. Enjoy that boost of energy in the afternoon, but do a 5-minute stretch after. It's not about being perfect; it's about finding balance and being aware of yourself. Every little change, like taking a deep breath before a meeting or having dinner without your phone, makes you more able to handle stress over time.
Just looking into these strategies means you're already on the right path. The first steps toward lasting change are being curious and having a goal. Some days will be easier than others, and that's okay. There is no one way to make progress, but every little bit helps. You should feel calm, energized, and in charge without giving up the little things that make you happy.